Who would you rather have at qb a fresh young Brady Quinn or a scared to be hit Trent Green?

As a chiefs fan I watched as Trent Green bailed out of the pocket, got rid of the ball way early and just plain played scared after getting his head darn near ripped off by the bengal. I just want to know what the heck the phins front office was thinking by ping on Brady and then working to sign this joker. Wow definitely not the 72 phins bring back Shula